
You know, only one year have I gone this long without splitting a story. I actually thought I might make it the whole month without a two-parter. Alas, this one got away from me – it needs space to breathe I couldn’t give it in one night. So, please enjoy the first part of this restoration.
Tessa smiled as she climbed out of her F-150 and shouldered her small tool bag. “Mr. Matheson, I didn’t think I’d see you again,” she shook the visibly nervous man’s hand. “You didn’t seem particularly happy when we last met.”
“That’s because your bid was ridiculously high and your ideas for renovating this house were… not what we were looking for.”
“And yet, here I am…” Tessa smiled, gesturing towards the old Craftsman Bungalow with siding removed and scaffolding around one side.
“Yes, well, we’ve had some… issues with the other contractors….” He pinched the bridge of his nose.
“Contractors? Plural?”
The man grimaced. “Yes, we’ve had three different contractors start and leave without warning. Only one has even returned our phone calls.”
“Oh? What did they have to say for themselves?” Tessa smiled.
The man fidgeted nervously. “They said…” he started and then mumbled something unintelligible.
“They said what?” Tessa asked again.
“They said… they said it’s haunted,” he said finally.
“Haunted?” Tessa said, turning to the house, nodding seriously. “Yeah, that makes sense…”
“It – what?”
Tessa stared at the house as she recited: “This is the Rutherford house. Built in 1911 by Edwin Rutherford and his brother Leland. When the Rutherford family finally sold it in 1965, the subsequent owners sold it sooner and sooner – first owner had it for fifteen years, the next thirteen, then ten… By the ‘80s the owners just rented it, but had trouble keeping tenants longer than a year. Eventually, it sat empty until you bought it.”
Mr. Matheson stared at her open-mouthed. “How… How do you know so much about this place?”
She looked at Matheson and smiled a little sadly. “Mr. Matheson, I don’t bid high for my health. I put in the work – that means before and during the job. When you asked for a quote, I pulled the records for this place. I like to know what I’m getting into. This place has had a lot of… trauma.”
“Trauma? I don’t understand, there’s been no reported deaths…”
“Well, there you’re wrong,” Tessa said. “Edwin and Lila lost their eldest son here in 1923.”
“How can you know that?”
“Homework, Mr. Matheson. Historical societies, microfiche at the library.”
“To… to what end, Ms. Calder?”
“Tessa, please,” she said. “A house is more than wood and plaster. It’s a culmination of materials, process, history, and intention.”
“Intention, Ms. Calder—err, Tessa? Pardon me for saying this, but that sounds a little… woo-woo.”
Tessa grinned, “That’s not the first time I’ve got that. Let’s check the place out and let it tell us what’s going on…” She walked towards the house leaving Matheson staring after her. She stepped gingerly up the steps onto the porch, listening to the way the wood creaked almost imperceptibly under her steps. She tilted her head at the green door with the inset windows before rapping her knuckles on the smooth surface. “Where’d you get this cheap door?”
“It matched the aesthetic we’re going for,” Matheson said as he hurried up onto the porch. “And it wasn’t cheap, let me tell you…”
“Hollow-core, synthetic finish… Please tell me they didn’t get rid of the original.”
“It’s in the garage,” he gestured towards the detached garage down the driveway.
“Okay, good. I have a guy who can restore it and get it to match what you’re looking for.”
“Is that really necessary? This door is perfectly fine…”
Tessa turned around and faced Matheson directly, speaking quietly yet firmly. “No, it’s not. That door’s the only thing every hand that ever lived here touched every day. You think you can just replace that and not change the house?”
“Change the…” Matheson sputtered.
Tessa ignored him and stepped inside. In the fading evening light, the pink light through the windows didn’t do much to illuminate the interior or cut the intense chill. Tessa pulled out her flashlight and shone it around the dim interior as Matheson stepped inside behind her.
“The power is currently off…” he explained unnecessarily but was cut off by a loud knocking coming from the south wall of the room, causing him to jump.
Tessa didn’t react except to continue calmly tracing the beam of her flashlight over the interior until she reached the wall with the knocking. “Ah, I hear you…” she said calmly as the light fixed on the white-painted brick fireplace. She walked towards the fireplace as the knocking got louder and more insistent.
“We… we can come back during the day,” Matheson said, edging towards the door.
“No, we’re good…” she said, pulling out a pry bar and hammer from her tool bag before setting it down. She ran her hand across the brick lining the firebox as the knocking continued. “Uh-huh,” she said softly, “I hear you…” She finally stopped, set the pry bar against the mortar between two bricks, and struck it with the hammer. Several quick blows later, a brick clattered to the floor — and as it fell, a gust of warm air swept through the room, carrying the scent of linseed oil and baked bread.
“What in gods name are you doing?!” Matheson yelled when the brick fell to the hearth. In the silence that followed, Matheson remarked, “The knocking… it’s stopped.”
Tessa had set her tools down and brought the flashlight up to the hole in the brickwork. “That’s what you’re trying to tell me,” she said quietly.
“What is it?” Matheson asked.
“Take a look,” she gestured him over. He moved to the hole. “See that color?” The flashlight played over dust-covered muted cobalt and wheat-gold glaze. “Hand-painted tiles. I’d bet that’s the original fireplace. It wants to be uncovered.”
“Your saying, the knocking… the haunting… is the house itself?”
“That’s exactly what I’m saying, Mr. Matheson.”
He looked from the broken brick to her calm face.
“You really believe that, don’t you?”
“I don’t have to believe it,” she said. “I can hear it.”
For a long moment he said nothing, then nodded once – small, defeated.
“All right,” he whispered. “Fix it.”
Tessa kept her eyes on the exposed tile, brushing soot from the painted wheat stalks.
“I’m not fixing it,” she said. “I’m letting it breathe. You’ve just got to give the heart of the house a little air.” She placed her hand on the exposed tile and closed her eyes as she felt the warmth from the tile and knew the house realized it was being heard.


